Hong Kong SFC Fines Investment Advisory Firm Cardinalasia Consulting $191,000 & Banned Founder Edward Lee for 9 Months, Unfair $26 Million Loan Agreements for 5 Funds & Executed 14 Cross-Trades Between Funds at 14% to 31% Discount
2nd February 2023 | Hong Kong
Hong Kong Securities & Futures Commission (SFC) has fined investment advisory firm Cardinalasia Consulting (CCL) $191,000 (HKD 1.5 million) and banned founder Edward Lee Shiu Lun for 9 months (Jan to Oct 2023), for entering into unfair $26 million (HKD 203.9 million) loan agreements for 5 funds and executing 14 cross-trades of stocks between funds at 14% to 31% discount (2015). Hong Kong SFC: “During its investigation, the SFC found that seven loan agreements totalling HKD 203.9 million were entered into amongst the five CCL-advised private funds for the sole purpose of addressing the borrowing funds’ liquidity needs (such as meeting margin calls), with little regard to the lending funds’ interests. The SFC is of the view that CCL and Lee had failed to ensure that five of the seven loans that they advised and/or recommended the funds to enter into were fair and in their best interests. As for the other two loans which CCL and Lee allegedly had no knowledge of until after they had been entered into, CCL and Lee did not raise any concerns with the funds’ investment managers after becoming aware of them even though they were not in the best interest of the lending funds … … The SFC’s investigation also found that the investment managers of the five CCL-advised funds effected a total of 14 pairs of cross trades amongst the funds by way of bought and sold notes at a significant discount (ranging from 14% to 31%) to the stocks’ previous close on three trading days in November 2015. In this connection, CCL and Lee had failed to properly assess the basis for each of the trades and ensure that they were executed on the best available terms for, and in the best interests of, both the buying and selling funds before signing the relevant settlement instruction forms for the trades.” See below for Hong Kong SFC full statement.
” Hong Kong SFC Fines Investment Advisory Firm Cardinalasia Consulting $191,000 & Banned Founder Edward Lee for 9 Months, Unfair $26 Million Loan Agreements for 5 Funds & Executed 14 Cross-Trades Between Funds at 14% to 31% Discount “
Securities and Futures Appeals Tribunal (SFAT) Chairman the Hon Justice Hartmann: “It is important that others acting in the same capacity should appreciate that the role of an investment adviser is a role of real substance. The clear importance of an investment adviser in protecting the interests of investors lies in the simple, single fact that the person so appointed acts in an independent way, even if acting under delegated powers, employing his or her knowledge and understanding of financial matters in order to ensure the best interests of investors even if, in giving advice, that advice is contrary to the intended wishes, or decisions actually made, of those higher in the delegated chain of management.”
Christopher Wilson, the SFC’s Executive Director of Enforcement: “This case serves as a timely reminder to fund managers and advisers of the high standards of conduct the SFC expects of them. Substandard practices of fund managers would not only expose fund investors to potentially significant financial losses, but also threaten the integrity of the market and Hong Kong’s role as an international asset management centre. The SFC is determined to crack down on asset management misconduct and will impose harsher penalties going forward to deter such misconduct.”
Cardinalasia Consulting Limited (CCL) was founded by Edward Lee in 2004 as a financial and investment advisory company. Edward has more than 25 years of experience in investment banks. The experienced team has developed extensive connection in Greater China especially in mainland which helps investors to better capture the opportunities generated by China’s “One Belt, One Road”. Hong Kong is the world’s leading offshore renminbi market and gateway for more than half the mainland’s outward investment. “One Belt, One Road” offers a historic opportunity to leverage its status as China’s most cosmopolitan city. Our existing clients include Hong Kong listed companies, state owned enterprises, regional property developers, private equity funds, institutional & hedge funds, family offices and high-net-worth Individuals. CCL is a limited company registered in Hong Kong and is a Hong Kong Securities and Future Commission (HKSFC) registered Licensed Corporation (CE No. AIN601) with Regulated Activities (RA) Type 4 (Advising on Securities) and Type 9 (Asset Management) Licenses. CCL is also a member of the Alternatives Investment Management Association Limited (AIMA).
Hong Kong SFC Statement
SFAT affirms SFC decision to fine Cardinalasia Consulting Limited $1.5 million and imposes a heavier suspension on its responsible officer for failures in managing private funds
30th Jan 2023 – The Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) has reprimanded and fined Cardinalasia Consulting Limited (CCL) $1.5 million over its failures in acting as a principal investment adviser to five private funds between August 2014 and October 2017 after the Securities and Futures Appeals Tribunal (SFAT) upheld the SFC’s disciplinary action against it (Notes 1 to 5).
The licence of CCL’s responsible officer, Mr Edward Lee Shiu Lun, has also been suspended for nine months from 27 January 2023 to 26 October 2023 – two months more than the SFC had proposed. Lee was primarily responsible for providing investment management and advisory services to the five CCL-advised private funds during the material time (Note 6).
During its investigation, the SFC found that seven loan agreements totalling $203.9 million were entered into amongst the five CCL-advised private funds for the sole purpose of addressing the borrowing funds’ liquidity needs (such as meeting margin calls), with little regard to the lending funds’ interests (Note 7). Specifically:
- the loans were not backed by any collateral or guarantee, and offered limited protection to the lending funds in the event of default or late repayment;
- one of the loans was granted free of interest, and the interest rates for the other loans were far below the rates offered by other execution brokers for margin loans; and
- it is apparent that one of the lending funds did not have sufficient liquidity when granting the loans. In one case, the lending fund had to borrow from another fund due to liquidity issues just one day after it had granted two loans to a third fund.
The SFC is of the view that CCL and Lee had failed to ensure that five of the seven loans that they advised and/or recommended the funds to enter into were fair and in their best interests. As for the other two loans which CCL and Lee allegedly had no knowledge of until after they had been entered into, CCL and Lee did not raise any concerns with the funds’ investment managers after becoming aware of them even though they were not in the best interest of the lending funds.
The SFC’s investigation also found that the investment managers of the five CCL-advised funds effected a total of 14 pairs of cross trades amongst the funds by way of bought and sold notes at a significant discount (ranging from 14% to 31%) to the stocks’ previous close on three trading days in November 2015. In this connection, CCL and Lee had failed to properly assess the basis for each of the trades and ensure that they were executed on the best available terms for, and in the best interests of, both the buying and selling funds before signing the relevant settlement instruction forms for the trades.
Notes:
- CCL is licensed under the Securities and Futures Ordinance (SFO) to carry on Type 4 (advising on securities) and Type 9 (asset management) regulated activities.
- Between August 2014 and October 2017, CCL was appointed by the funds’ investment managers as the principal investment adviser responsible for providing investment management and advisory services in respect of the funds.
- The funds, which were incorporated under the laws of the Cayman Islands as exempted companies with limited liability, are: (i) Taiping Quantum China Opportunities Fund; (ii) Taiping Quantum Strategic Fund; (iii) Taiping Quantum Prosperity Fund (Prosperity Fund); (iv) Quantum Advantage Fund; and (v) Quantum Enhanced Fund (Enhanced Fund).
- Prior to August 2015, Quantum China Asset Management Limited (QCAML) acted as the investment managers of all five funds. On 3 August 2015, Nova Asia Asset Management Limited (formerly known as Quantum Asia Asset Management Limited, NAAM), replaced QCAML as the investment manager of Prosperity Fund and Enhanced Fund. Both QCAML and NAAM were incorporated in the Cayman Islands and were not licensed by the SFC to carry on a business in any regulated activities as defined in the SFO during the relevant period.
- Please see the SFAT’s determination for SFAT Application No. 2 of 2021 on its website.
- Lee has been a responsible officer of CCL since 27 June 2003 and is licensed to carry on Type 4 (advising on securities) and Type 9 (asset management) regulated activities under the SFO.
- Two of the loans were partially repaid (for the total sum of $38.3 million) and the other five loans have been defaulted.
Sign Up / Register
Caproasia Users
- Manage $20 million to $3 billion of assets
- Invest $3 million to $300 million
- Advise institutions, billionaires, UHNWs & HNWs
Caproasia Platforms | 11,000 Investors & Advisors
- Caproasia.com
- Caproasia Access
- Caproasia Events
- The Financial Centre | Find Services
- Membership
- Family Office Circle
- Professional Investor Circle
- Investor Relations Network
Monthly Roundtable & Networking
Family Office Programs
The 2024 Investment Day
- March 2024 - Hong Kong
- March 2024 - Singapore
- June 2024 - Hong Kong
- June 2024 - Singapore
- Sept 2024 - Hong Kong
- Sept 2024 - Singapore
- Visit: The Investment Day | Register: Click here
Caproasia Summits
- The Investment Summit
- The Private Wealth Summit
- The Family Office Summit
- The CEO & Entrepreneur Summit
- The Capital Markets Summit
- The ESG / Sustainable Investment Summit
