Credit Suisse Zurich
Caproasia.com | The leading source of data, research, information & resource for financial professionals, investment managers, professional investors, family offices & advisors to institutions, billionaires, UHNWs & HNWs. Covering capital markets, investments and private wealth in Asia. How do you invest $3 million to $300 million? How do you manage $20 million to $3 billion of assets? Caproasia - Learn more



This site is for accredited investors, professional investors, investment managers and financial professionals only. You should have assets around $3 million to $300 million or managing $20 million to $3 billion.










Switzerland Regulator Concludes $10 Billion Supply Chain Fund Greensill Proceeding Against Credit Suisse, Serious Breach of Supervisory & Risk Management and 4 Enforcements to be Taken Against Credit Suisse Managers

2nd March 2023 | Hong Kong

Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) has concluded the $10 billion supply chain fund Greensill proceeding against Credit Suisse, with key findings including serious breach of supervisory & risk management and  4 enforcements to be taken against Credit Suisse Managers.  On Structure of Funds: FINMA’s investigation showed that overall Credit Suisse’s asset management company had little knowledge and control over the specific claims. In fact, it was not Credit Suisse as asset manager of the funds that selected and reviewed them, but Greensill itself. Credit Suisse also left it to the latter to arrange the insurance cover in its own name.  On Buying Possible Future Claims: FINMA’s investigation showed that Credit Suisse did not initially realise the consequences of this change. In addition, Credit Suisse had no knowledge or control over how many claims were actually contractually owed. In this context, it relied on the insurance cover organised by Greensill.   On IPO Due Diligence: Greensill, for its part, announced to the bank that it was planning an IPO with Credit Suisse. Greensill first needed a bridging loan. The Credit Suisse risk manager responsible for the loan identified a number of risks in Greensill’s business model. He therefore recommended internally at the bank not to grant the loan. A senior manager overruled this recommendation. FINMA: “the bank’s most important (approximately 500) business relationships are to be reviewed periodically and holistically for counterparty risks at executive board level. In addition, the areas of responsibility of the bank’s (approximately 600) highest managers must in future be recorded in a document of responsibility.”  See below for full statement on Credit Suisse / Greensill:

“ Switzerland Regulator Concludes $10 Billion Supply Chain Fund Greensill Proceeding Against Credit Suisse, Serious Breach of Supervisory & Risk Management and 4 Enforcements to be Taken Against Credit Suisse Managers “

 



- Article continues below -



Sign Up
Basic Member: $5 Monthly | $60 Yearly
Newsletter Daily 2 pm (Promo): $20 Monthly | $180 Yearly (FP: $680)


The 2024 Investment Day
6th March Hong Kong | 13th March Singapore

Private Equity, Hedge Funds, Boutique Funds, Private Markets & more. Taking place on 6th March 2024 in Hong Kong, 13th March 2024 in Singapore.
Visit | Register here


The 2024 Family Office Summit
10th April Hong Kong | 24th April Singapore

Join 100+ single family offices & family office professionals in Hong Kong & Singapore
Links: 2024 Family Office Summit | Register here





 

FINMA is Switzerland’s independent financial-markets regulator. Its mandate is to supervise banks, insurance companies, financial institutions, collective investment schemes, and their asset managers and fund management companies. It also regulates insurance intermediaries. It is charged with protecting creditors, investors and policyholders. FINMA is responsible for ensuring that Switzerland’s financial markets function effectively.

 

 

FINMA concludes “Greensill” proceedings against Credit Suisse

Credit Suisse Zurich

28th Feb 2023 – The Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority FINMA has concluded its enforcement proceedings against Credit Suisse in connection with its business relationship with financier Lex Greensill and his companies. FINMA finds that Credit Suisse seriously breached its supervisory obligations in this context with regard to risk management and appropriate organisational structures. FINMA has ordered remedial measures. In future, the bank will have to periodically review at executive board level the most important business relationships (around 500) in particular for counterparty risks. In addition, the bank is required to record the responsibilities of its approximately 600 highest-ranking employees in a responsibility document. FINMA has also opened four enforcement proceedings against former Credit Suisse managers.

 

Background

In March 2021, Credit Suisse closed four funds at short notice that were related to companies of the financier Lex Greensill (hereinafter referred to as “Greensill”). These funds were distributed to qualified investors, whereupon their risk was indicated as low in the client documentation. At the time of the closure, clients had invested a total of around ten billion US dollars in the aforementioned funds. Immediately after the closure of the funds in March 2021, FINMA took various risk-reducing measures and opened enforcement proceedings. The focus was on the question of whether the Credit Suisse Group had violated Swiss supervisory law in its business relationship with Greensill.

 

1) Structure of the funds

In 2017, Credit Suisse launched the first of four funds in the area of supply chain finance in collaboration with Greensill. With this type of financing, the purchase price of a good with a respite is immediately refunded by a financing company (instead of the actual buyer) with a discount. In return, the financing company receives a claim against the actual buyer. If the buyer pays the full purchase price, the financing company makes a profit. Greensill acted as a financing company, securitised the claims and transferred the securities to the four Credit Suisse funds. It was planned that specific insurance cover would secure the majority of the claims against a default of buyers.

FINMA’s investigation showed that overall Credit Suisse’s asset management company had little knowledge and control over the specific claims. In fact, it was not Credit Suisse as asset manager of the funds that selected and reviewed them, but Greensill itself. Credit Suisse also left it to the latter to arrange the insurance cover in its own name. 

 

2) The funds also purchased possible future claims

Over time, the risk character of the funds changed decisively. In some instances, Greensill additionally transferred future claims to the funds that had not yet arisen and therefore also expectations of a company about possible future claims. By selling future claims to the Credit Suisse funds, Greensill financed some companies whose creditworthiness was doubtful.

FINMA’s investigation showed that Credit Suisse did not initially realise the consequences of this change. In addition, Credit Suisse had no knowledge or control over how many claims were actually contractually owed. In this context, it relied on the insurance cover organised by Greensill. 

 

3) Many critical observations, too few appropriate reactions

The closure of a fund at another fund provider that had also worked with Greensill led to enquiries at Credit Suisse in 2018 about the funds associated with Greensill. Media representatives repeatedly approached the Credit Suisse executive board with critical questions and information. FINMA also repeatedly asked critical questions of the banking group’s governing bodies about its business relationship with Greensill and the associated risks.

Greensill, for its part, announced to the bank that it was planning an IPO with Credit Suisse. Greensill first needed a bridging loan. The Credit Suisse risk manager responsible for the loan identified a number of risks in Greensill’s business model. He therefore recommended internally at the bank not to grant the loan. A senior manager overruled this recommendation.

As FINMA’s investigation revealed, the bank used employees who were themselves responsible for the business relationship with Greensill and were therefore not independent to deal with critical questions or warnings. Credit Suisse even repeatedly asked Lex Greensill himself and relied on his answers for its own statements. For these reasons, the bank made partly false and overly positive statements to FINMA about the claims selection process and the funds’ exposure to certain debtors. 

 

4) Deficiencies in risk management and organisational structures

In its proceedings, FINMA concluded that Credit Suisse Group seriously breached its supervisory duty to adequately identify, limit and monitor risks in the context of the business relationship with Lex Greensill over a period of years. FINMA also found serious deficiencies in the bank’s organisational structures during the period under investigation. Furthermore, it did not sufficiently fulfil its supervisory duties as an asset manager. FINMA thus concludes that there has been a serious breach of Swiss supervisory law.

 

5) Internal investigation by Credit Suisse

Credit Suisse has adopted a wide range of organisational measures based on its own investigation of the case. Governance structures were revised and control processes strengthened, namely in the approval and monitoring of fund products. FINMA supports these measures. At the same time, FINMA is ordering a number of other measures to further improve the banking group’s risk management and governance.

 

6) Measures imposed by FINMA

The business relationship with Greensill was repeatedly discussed at Credit Suisse management level. However, this was usually only done selectively because of a specific event or request. There was a lack of an overall view as well as regular, consistent engagement with the risks associated with Greensill at the highest level. FINMA therefore orders the banking group to prospectively assess its significant business relationships according to risks. From now on, the bank’s most important (approximately 500) business relationships are to be reviewed periodically and holistically for counterparty risks at executive board level. In addition, the areas of responsibility of the bank’s (approximately 600) highest managers must in future be recorded in a document of responsibility. If they do not organise and manage their business area in such a way that misconduct is prevented as far as possible, they must be sanctioned by the bank, for example through a reduction of their variable compensation. FINMA will appoint an audit mandatary to review compliance with these supervisory measures.

 

7) Clarification of individual responsibilities 

FINMA has also opened four enforcement proceedings against former Credit Suisse managers. FINMA will not comment further on these proceedings, particularly not on the identity of the persons concerned.

Proceedings against  individuals as a FINMA enforcement tool

FINMA can ban individuals who are responsible for a serious breach of supervisory law from acting in a senior role at an institution it supervises. The prohibition from practising a profession may be imposed for a period of up to five years. FINMA has made increasing use of the tool of imposing an industry ban in particular since 2014. It has issued a total of around 60 such bans. Managers at all levels of organisations were affected.  The measure has a preventive character. Its purpose in particular is to prevent the person concerned or other financial market players from committing similar violations of the law in the future. As a supervisory authority tasked primarily with preventing future damage within its supervisory remit, FINMA can also waive industry and activity bans if individuals have left the supervised sector for good.  To issue an industry ban, FINMA must be able to prove direct, individual and causal responsibility for the serious violation of supervisory law. There must be a proven breach of duty (for example, omissions that are in breach of duty) that has specifically led to these violations. It is not sufficient under supervisory law to construe responsibility for legal violations solely from a person’s hierarchical level or position.

 

FINMA

FINMA is Switzerland’s independent financial-markets regulator. Its mandate is to supervise banks, insurance companies, financial institutions, collective investment schemes, and their asset managers and fund management companies. It also regulates insurance intermediaries. It is charged with protecting creditors, investors and policyholders. FINMA is responsible for ensuring that Switzerland’s financial markets function effectively.

Credit Suisse

Credit Suisse is one of the world’s leading financial services providers. The bank’s strategy builds on its core strengths: its position as a leading wealth manager, its specialist investment banking and asset management capabilities and its strong presence in its home market of Switzerland. Credit Suisse seeks to follow a balanced approach to wealth management, aiming to capitalize on both the large pool of wealth within mature markets as well as the significant growth in wealth in Asia Pacific and other emerging markets, while also serving key developed markets with an emphasis on Switzerland. The bank employs more than 50,000 people. The registered shares (CSGN) of Credit Suisse Group AG, are listed in Switzerland and, in the form of American Depositary Shares (CS), in New York. Further information about Credit Suisse can be found at www.credit-suisse.com.




Managing $20 million to $3 billion. Investing $3 million to $300 million.
For Investment Managers, Hedge Funds, Boutique Funds, Private Equity, Venture Capital, Professional Investors, Family Offices, Private Bankers & Advisors, sign up today. Subscribe to Caproasia and receive the latest news, data, insights & reports, events & programs daily at 2 pm.

Join Events & Find Services
Join Investments, Private Wealth, Family Office events in Hong Kong, Singapore, Asia-wide. Find hard-to-find $3 million to $300 million financial & investment services at The Financial Centre | TFC. Find financial, investment, private wealth, family office, real estate, luxury investments, citizenship, law firms & more.  List hard-to-find financial & private wealth services.

Have a product launch? Promote a product or service? List your service at The Financial Centre | TFC. Join interviews & editorial and be featured on Caproasia.com or join Investments, Private Wealth, Family Office events. Contact us at [email protected] or [email protected]

Caproasia.com | The leading source of data, research, information & resource for financial professionals, investment managers, professional investors, family offices & advisors to institutions, billionaires, UHNWs & HNWs. Covering capital markets, investments and private wealth in Asia. How do you invest $3 million to $300 million? How do you manage $20 million to $3 billion of assets?



Quick Links


2021 Data Release
2020 List of Private Banks in Hong Kong
2020 List of Private Banks in Singapore
2020 Top 10 Largest Family Office
2020 Top 10 Largest Multi-Family Offices
2020 Report: Hong Kong Private Banks & Asset Mgmt - $4.49 Trillion
2020 Report: Singapore Asset Mgmt - $3.48 Trillion AUM


For Investors | Professionals | Executives
Latest data, reports, insights, news, events & programs
Everyday at 2 pm
Direct to your inbox
Save 2 to 8 hours per week. Organised for success

Register Below

For CEOs, Heads, Senior Management, Market Heads, Desk Heads, Financial Professionals, Investment Managers, Asset Managers, Fund Managers, Hedge Funds, Boutique Funds, Analysts, Advisors, Wealth Managers, Private Bankers, Family Offices, Investment Bankers, Private Equity, Institutional Investors, Professional Investors

Get Ahead in 60 Seconds. Join 10,000 +
Save 2 to 8 hours weekly. Organised for Success.

Sign Up / Register


    InvestorProfessionalFamily OfficeExecutive


    SubscriptionMembershipEvents


    Professional InvestorPrivate WealthFamily OfficePrivate BankingWealth ManagementInvestmentsAlternativesPrivate MarketsCapital MarketsESG & SICEO & EntrepreneursTax, Legal & RisksHNW & UHNWs Insights










    Web links may be disabled on mobile for security.
    Please click on desktop.










    Caproasia Users

    • Manage $20 million to $3 billion of assets
    • Invest $3 million to $300 million
    • Advise institutions, billionaires, UHNWs & HNWs

    Caproasia Platforms | 11,000 Investors & Advisors

    Monthly Roundtable & Networking

    Family Office Programs

    The 2024 Investment Day

    • March 2024 - Hong Kong
    • March 2024 - Singapore
    • June 2024 - Hong Kong
    • June 2024 - Singapore
    • Sept 2024 - Hong Kong
    • Sept 2024 - Singapore
    • Visit: The Investment Day | Register: Click here

    Caproasia Summits

    Contact Us

    For Enquiries, Membership
    [email protected], [email protected]

    For Listing, Subscription
    [email protected], [email protected]

    For Press Release, send to:
    [email protected]

    For Events & Webinars
    [email protected]

    For Media Kit, Advertising, Sponsorships, Partnerships
    [email protected]

    For Research, Data, Surveys, Reports
    [email protected]

    For General Enquiries
    [email protected]





    Caproasia | Driving the future of Asia
    a financial information technology co.
    since 2014




    Previous articleHSBC Singapore Launches Instant Account Opening for International Customers Providing Access to Bank Accounts Before Relocating to Singapore, Top Concerns of International Citizens Include Struggling to Setup Bank Accounts & Managing Personal Finance
    Next articleSingapore Global Investor Program Increased to Minimum S$10 Million in Business or S$25 Million into Approved Funds from 15th March 2023, Family Office Requires S$200 Million AUM with S$50 Million Invested into 1 of 4 Categories: Qualifying Debt Securities, Certificates of Deposits, Singapore-Licensed Fund Managers or Private Equity into Non-Listed Singapore-Based Business
    Caproasia.com covering capital markets, investments and private wealth in Asia. Our users manage, advise & invest $25 trillion assets in Asia